ICMAI’s Push for Tax Audit Authority: A New Chapter for CMAs?

The Institute of Cost Accountants of India (ICMAI) has recently initiated a major proposal to allow Cost and Management Accountants (CMAs) to conduct tax audits under the proposed Income Tax Bill, 2025. Currently, only Chartered Accountants (CAs) have the authority to conduct tax audits under the Income Tax Act. If approved, this change could significantly reshape the role of CMAs in India's taxation landscape.

In this article, we will explore:

• ICMAI's demand for tax audit authority
• Current legal position on tax audits
• The opposition from ICAI (Institute of Chartered Accountants of India)
• Government’s role and next steps
• Impact on CMAs, businesses, and tax compliance in India

---

ICMAI's Demand: Why Should CMAs Be Allowed to Conduct Tax Audits?

1. CMAs Are Experts in Taxation & Compliance

ICMAI argues that CMAs undergo rigorous training in taxation, financial management, cost accounting, and auditing, making them fully capable of conducting tax audits. Their syllabus covers:

• Direct and indirect taxation (including GST and Income Tax)
• Corporate and financial laws
• Financial reporting and auditing
• Cost control and management accounting

ICMAI believes that excluding CMAs from tax audits limits their professional scope and restricts competition in the auditing industry.

2. CMAs Already Perform Internal and Cost Audits

CMAs are already recognized under various laws for auditing and certification functions, including:

• Internal audit under the Companies Act, 2013
• Cost audit under the Companies (Cost Records and Audit) Rules, 2014
• GST Audits (before its removal in 2021)

Since CMAs already conduct these audits, ICMAI believes they should also be allowed to conduct tax audits under the Income Tax Act.

3. Promoting Healthy Competition & Better Compliance

At present, only Chartered Accountants (CAs) can conduct tax audits, which means businesses must rely solely on CAs for tax audit reports. By allowing CMAs, the tax audit market will open up to greater competition, reducing monopolization and improving service quality.

4. Strengthening India's Tax Compliance System

ICMAI has argued that allowing CMAs to conduct tax audits would lead to:

• More professionals available for tax audit services
• Improved compliance and accuracy in tax reporting
• More accountability in business financials

The institute has submitted its recommendation to the Lok Sabha’s Select Committee, requesting an amendment to the definition of "Accountant" under Section 515(3)(b) of the new Income Tax Bill to include CMAs.

---

Current Legal Position on Tax Audits

As per Section 44AB of the Income Tax Act, 1961, only Chartered Accountants (CAs) are allowed to conduct tax audits. Businesses with turnover above a specified limit must get their accounts audited by a CA before filing their income tax returns.

The new Income Tax Bill, 2025, introduced in Parliament, aims to simplify tax laws and redefine various provisions. ICMAI is now advocating for CMAs to be recognized as "Accountants" under the new law, which would legally permit them to conduct tax audits.

---

ICAI’s Opposition: Why CAs Are Against This Proposal?

1. ICAI Claims That Tax Audits Should Remain with CAs

The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India (ICAI) strongly opposes ICMAI’s demand. ICAI believes that tax audits require specialized expertise, which only CAs possess.

2. Supreme Court and High Court Rulings in Favor of CAs

ICAI cites multiple Supreme Court and High Court judgments that have upheld CAs' exclusive right to conduct tax audits. ICAI President Charanjot Singh Nanda recently stated:

"Auditing is a specialized field that requires extensive training and regulatory oversight, which is why the courts have upheld CAs as the sole professionals authorized for tax audits."

3. ICAI Fears Dilution of Audit Standards

ICAI also argues that allowing CMAs to conduct tax audits could lead to a decline in audit quality, as CMAs do not specialize in financial auditing the same way CAs do.

4. The Monopoly Argument: Does ICAI Want to Keep Control?

While ICAI’s concerns about audit quality may be valid, many argue that ICAI is simply trying to maintain its monopoly over tax audits. If CMAs are allowed to perform tax audits, businesses will have more options for audit services, reducing ICAI’s dominance in the field.

---

Government’s Role: What Happens Next?

The Income Tax Bill, 2025 has been referred to a parliamentary select committee for review. During this process, the government will consider various recommendations, including ICMAI’s proposal.

The key decision-makers in this matter include:

• Finance Ministry – Final authority on tax law amendments
• CBDT (Central Board of Direct Taxes) – Regulatory body overseeing tax compliance
• Parliamentary Select Committee – Reviews and recommends changes to tax laws

Possible Outcomes

1. CMAs Get Tax Audit Rights – If the government amends the bill, CMAs will be legally allowed to conduct tax audits.
2. Status Quo Remains – If ICAI’s opposition is successful, tax audits will remain exclusive to CAs.
3. Partial Recognition for CMAs – The government may allow CMAs to conduct tax audits only for specific industries or business categories.

---

Impact on CMAs, Businesses, and Tax Compliance

1. Benefits for CMAs

• Expanded career opportunities for CMAs
• Increased professional recognition and demand
• Better utilization of CMAs' expertise in taxation and auditing

2. Impact on Businesses

• More choices for tax audit professionals
• Potentially lower audit costs due to increased competition
• Improved compliance with tax laws

3. The Future of Tax Audits in India

If CMAs are granted tax audit rights, it could pave the way for further recognition of CMAs in financial auditing, GST audits, and other regulatory roles.

---

Final Thoughts: Will ICMAI’s Demand Be Accepted?

The battle between ICAI and ICMAI over tax audit authority is a significant issue that could redefine the role of CMAs in India's financial ecosystem. While ICAI argues for exclusive control, ICMAI makes a strong case for expanding tax audit rights to CMAs, citing their expertise and the benefits of competition.

The final decision lies with the government. If the amendment is passed, CMAs will gain a major professional breakthrough, opening up new opportunities in taxation and audit services.

The upcoming months will be crucial for CMAs, businesses, and policymakers as the debate over tax audits unfolds. Stay tuned to CMA Knowledge for the latest updates!

---

Do You Think CMAs Should Be Allowed to Conduct Tax Audits?

Drop your opinions in the comments below!

🔔 Subscribe to CMA Knowledge for More Updates on Finance & Accounting